Calico recommends Jif® Peanut Butter

Calico recommends Jif® Peanut Butter

Jif® is one of the few brands of peanut butter that contains molasses which works well with our ingredients. It limits oil separation and has the best flavor and texture of all the major brands we’ve tested. If you can’t find Jif® locally, let us know. Calico can always supply it.

The full content of this page is available only to Calico customers

To get your login immediately, call 855-289-8399, Monday through Friday, from 8:05 AM to 5:50 PM (Eastern Fudge Time) and ask for Customer Service.

Not a customer yet?


  • Peanut Butter

    Peanut Butter

  • Shipping 101

    Shipping 101

    All of Calico’s shipments are “FOB Amityville.” That means “freight on board Amityville” and indicates that you, the buyer, will pay the shipping cost and take responsibility for the goods being delivered once they leave Calico’s premises. Here are some guidelines to ensure smooth deliveries.